A Fatal Halloween

Chapter 6: The Trial

Edward Quan ·

Chen Fang insisted the noose was only a prop. His messages showed that he'd moved the ladder so I wouldn't have anything to stand on.

In the end, prosecutors decided to hold each of them accountable according to what they'd known and the part they'd played. Xu Tang and Gu Yanshen both understood that my life was in immediate danger, yet they kept the photo shoot going. One stopped anyone from helping. The other personally took away the only support I had left.

The other three helped create the danger, let it play out, then deleted evidence and agreed on a story. None of them could claim to have been a bystander.

When the indictment arrived, it was the first time the five heard one another's charges through their cell doors. Every last one of them shouted that they hadn't been the one behind it.

***

At the trial, I finally got to hear all of them tell a roomful of people why nobody had helped me.

Xu Tang choked up several times. “I only wanted Qinghe to fit in with us. We never meant to kill anyone. It really was just a joke…”

Her lawyer repeatedly stressed that none of it had been planned with the intention of killing anyone, and that no one had wanted it to end in a death.

Yanshen testified too. “When I let go, I thought she was still upset with me. Whenever she felt she'd been wronged, she'd go quiet. I thought she was trying to make me end the photo shoot.”

I floated above the gallery and watched Dad grip Mom's hand. Even in court, Yanshen could make my fight for air sound like an attempt to get my way.

The prosecutor didn't argue. They simply asked to play the original video.

As laughter from the studio filled the room, the courtroom went silent. Yanshen suddenly lost control and screamed at Xu Tang.

“You ruined my life! If you hadn't insisted on those pictures, why would I have let go?”

Xu Tang stopped crying. “Do you really think I was controlling you? Shen Qinghe was understanding. She let things go. I depended on you and made you feel important. You wanted what you got from both of us. Why pretend you're innocent now?”

Yanshen opened his mouth, but nothing came out.

Then Zhou Xu, Chen Fang, and Lin Yue each rushed to give their side. Zhou Xu said Xu Tang had sent him to buy the drug, but admitted he knew what it did. Chen Fang maintained the noose was a prop, but admitted he'd moved the ladder. Lin Yue insisted she'd warned everyone about the danger. Under cross-examination, she had to admit she'd kept filming afterward and had even helped delete the footage.

Every time one of them took a step back to avoid responsibility, the evidence put them right back where they stood.

At sentencing, the court found all five guilty. Xu Tang had made the plan, repeatedly stopped people from helping, and gone back to the scene in the middle of the night without calling the police. She received the heaviest sentence.

Yanshen knew I was in danger yet took away the support he was giving me and left me behind after I'd stopped responding. He received a severe sentence too.

Zhou Xu, Chen Fang, and Lin Yue were sentenced for their respective roles involving the drug, the dangerous equipment, the filming, and the concealment of evidence. All five were held jointly liable for civil damages.

When the judge's gavel came down, nobody was laughing anymore.

I watched them being led away one by one. The group picture they'd been so determined to get right never became the keepsake they'd wanted. It went into the case file as evidence of how they'd stood by and watched me die.

***

The verdict sent them to prison. It couldn't turn back time for any of them.

Yanshen was the first to lose his job. His company terminated his employment, and his former business partners refused to work with him again. His family sold the house that was meant to be our first home together to pay damages.

We'd picked out the key ring for that house together. “This is going to be our home,” he'd told me then.

Now the keys were handed to a real estate agent. The red double-happiness emblem we'd planned to put on the front door had never even gone up.

In prison, Yanshen repeatedly asked to exchange letters with Xu Tang. Maybe he still wanted to ask her one question.

Why?

Xu Tang gave him no answer. All she sent was paperwork from her appeal. It said the plan had been made on the spur of the moment, and that stopping people from helping had been an error of judgment.